By a 4-3 vote, Clinton City Council on Monday night moved forward the annexation of land out past Ingles, on Hwy 56 South, for the proposed Cambridge Farms subdivision.
This request was before the City a year ago, and passed a council vote with stipulations. Instead of complying with the stipulations, the developers chose to apply to Laurens County for permission to build under the county’s subdivision ordinance (the county does not have zoning, the city does have zoning).
That County process was moved forward by a technical review team but rejected by the Laurens County Planning Commission on a 5-0 vote; the developer sued and won, and that legal matter seems now headed for an appeal.
Four Clinton City Council members — Mayor Randy Randall, and members Danny Cook, Danny Smith, and Megan Walsh - set aside the legal dispute and voted “yes” to bring the land into the city limits.
Three Council members - Anita Williams, Natalie Cogsdill and Gary Kuykendall - voted “no” citing opposition from nearby, but outside the city limits, residents that the project is too big to be effectively managed by the city and, in essence, will be a “City within a City.”
During discussion, Williams said council member Smith should consider recusing himself, because Smith is a Realtor.
Smith, backed up by City Attorney Allen Wham, said he does not consider it a conflict of interest that his firm could show potential buyers “what’s out there” in terms of buying a house in Clinton, including Veranda Homes’ offerings in Cambridge Farms, once the 3-different-price-points houses are built.
“At least it (recusal) is on the record,” Williams said.
Also, Williams said she had not been invited to reported informal meetings about the project; and Cook clarified that he had never been “summoned” to a meeting, but that he initiated some meetings and phone calls about Cambridge Farms as part of his fact-finding mission.
Cook said any council member is entitled to make any contacts he/she wants to “get the job done” in representing constituents.
Portraying himself as the “swing vote,” Cook made the most extensive explanation of his vote, at the council’s regular meeting which was changed from the normal 1st Monday because of Labor Day.
“This town is special. This downtown is dying,” Cook said, in explaining why a 490-home subdivision would, in his mind, benefit Clinton.
The annexation was recommended to the council by the Clinton Planning Commission, also on a split vote. Six people spoke in opposition at the Sept. 14 Clinton City Council meeting, no one from the public spoke in favor although favorable comments had been presented at previous meetings.
The matter will come to the Council for a 2nd vote in October.
“I’m the deciding vote,” Cook said. “This has not been an easy thing for me. I have been on the phone, I have been in people’s homes. I have met with city staff, I have done my own homework. I appreciate every e-mail, every text. This has been the biggest thing in front of this city in a very long time,” he said — “a very long time,” he said for emphasis.
Cook said he did not like the process that the City went through to discuss this issue with the Cambridge Farms developers. He said Clinton government needs a full-time professional planner and a full-time professional economic developer.
“We have to take the city manager and the finance director out of the role of bringing these projects to the council to consider,” Cook said. “They play a vital role, and they’re very good at their jobs; but we’re going to a point in time where now, moving forward, we have to have the right kind of people — more hands, more heads to make these decisions may make a world of difference. …
“If we don’t get people coming and living here, and not jumping in their cars to run to Simpsonville, Fountain Inn, Maudlin, Greenville, Spartanburg, Greenwood, Newberry, we’re going to see more store closures. Our school district, it doesn’t matter if (a student is) in city limits or not, funding matters are based on the number of students they have in the classroom. We need to grow our school district.
“In the 2010 census there 2,000 more people here than in the 2020 census. That’s not a good stat to brag about.”
Cook reflected that, right now, inflation is up, gas prices are up, interest rates are up, home-buying is down - so the future is hard to predict. But, he said, public policy decisions need to be made on the here-and-now, not what conditions might be next year, or even 5 - 10 years from now when an ambitious subdivision like Cambridge Farms will be at build-out.
He said, however, that the one certainty is the City of Clinton must do a better job with its roads.
“I rode through the townhomes and there were so many cars parked on the street I couldn’t get through the street. That scares me when we have fire and rescue needing to get through. We have got to have, when we have a development, we’ve got to be on top of it. All the way. To make sure it is built the way we want it built, with the green space we want, with the amenities we want.
“But, also, we have to be a give and take society. If we don’t, it’s not going to work. We’ve seen too many towns dry up or become just small entities. Some cities go bankrupt - now, we’re not close to that, we’re not - but if we can’t find a way to grow, both in rooftops, in businesses and economic development, then we might might be at some point in time in the future.
“Right now in talking to the city manager on Friday, we have no one looking at us from an economic development standpoint, right now. That may have changed today, and I hope it did, but as of Friday we did not (have any economic development prospects).”
He observed that even a “boom town” like Woodruff — with a massive investment in an electric vehicles plant by BMW, and a new high school just opened — cannot attract a second grocery store.
“We have been told many times over it takes rooftops to get businesses, restaurants, and other kinds of entities. We’re not Woodruff - it’s a great small town and my wife is from there - (but) we are Clinton, South Carolina, and we want to do great things, now and in the future; and, folks, while we see some of this growth, it might not do what we want it to do for us; I’ve got some more homework to do between first reading and second reading, but I can’t kill it tonight.
“I will not make everybody happy. My job is a judiciary responsibility and to look at the whole picture.”
A retired banker, Cook indicated that he had a talk with another banker recently about housing and Cambridge Farms’ potential, and “I feel a little more at easy than I did a week ago.”
The Sept. 14 Council meeting lasted 1 hour and 46 minutes, and the majority of that time was the 1st reading of the Cambridge Farms annexation ordinance (council also gave first reading to an amended comprehensive plan and first reading to commercial zoning at the intersection of Willard Road and Springdale Drive for a potential RV sales and service business). Oct. 5 is the next Clinton City Council meeting date, barring any reason to have a called, or emergency, meeting. The Planning Commission already has fulfilled the city ordinance requirement to have one public hearing about annexation and/or zoning matters.